TG-RS-3
TrustGate Replay Specification Appendices
APPENDIX A — Canonical Replay Artifact Catalog
A.1. Purpose
This appendix defines the canonical catalog of replay artifacts recognized by the TrustGate Replay Specification.
Replay artifacts represent immutable constitutional objects produced, consumed, or referenced by the Canonical Replay Pipeline (CRP). They provide the foundation for deterministic replay, explainability, federation, and long-term assurance.
This appendix is normative.
A.2. Constitutional Principles
Every replay artifact shall:
- possess a canonical identity;
- be immutable once published;
- participate in constitutional lineage;
- support deterministic replay;
- preserve provenance;
- support federation where applicable;
- be independently verifiable.
Replay artifacts are constitutional artifacts and shall not be treated as transient runtime objects.
A.3. Replay Artifact Families
Replay artifacts are organized into constitutional families.
| Family | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Replay Context | Defines the execution environment for replay |
| Replay Contracts | Defines what shall be replayed |
| Replay Packages | Collects replayable constitutional artifacts |
| Replay Results | Records replay outcomes |
| Replay Telemetry | Captures replay execution metadata |
| Replay Archives | Supports long-term preservation |
| Replay Intelligence | Links replay to TG-INTEL |
| Federation Replay | Supports cross-ECO replay verification |
A.4. Canonical Replay Artifact Catalog
| Artifact | Identifier | Constitutional Purpose | Produced By | Consumed By |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Replay Execution | RPID | Identifies a replay execution | Replay Runtime | CRP |
| Replay Context | RCID | Immutable replay execution context | Context Engine | All replay engines |
| Replay Manifest | RMID | Defines replay contract and scope | Replay Orchestrator | CRP |
| Replay Package | RPKID | Immutable package of replayable artifacts | Package Engine | Replay Runtime, Federation |
| Replay Result | RRID | Final replay outcome | Result Engine | APIs, Federation |
| Replay Session | RSID | Groups related replay executions | Orchestrator | Runtime |
| Replay Telemetry | RTID | Runtime telemetry and diagnostics | Telemetry Engine | Monitoring, Analytics |
| Replay Archive | RAID | Long-term replay preservation | Archive Service | Audit, Regulators |
| Replay Intelligence Link | TIID | Connects replay to TG-INTEL | TG-INTEL | Intelligence Platform |
| Replay Federation Exchange | RFID | Exchange package for federated replay | Federation Engine | Partner ECOs |
A.5. Constitutional Artifact Relationships
Replay artifacts form immutable constitutional relationships.
Replay Execution (RPID)
│
├────────► Replay Context (RCID)
│
├────────► Replay Manifest (RMID)
│
├────────► Replay Package (RPKID)
│
├────────► Replay Result (RRID)
│
├────────► Replay Telemetry (RTID)
│
├────────► Replay Archive (RAID)
│
└────────► TG-INTEL (TIID)
These relationships preserve constitutional lineage and shall remain immutable.
A.6. Constitutional Dependencies
Replay artifacts may reference, but shall not duplicate, other constitutional artifacts.
Representative dependencies include:
- CSI;
- USO;
- TG-SIGNAL;
- TG-VRES;
- VEVID;
- TOID;
- TVID;
- TAID;
- DAL Anchors;
- Federation Exchange identifiers.
Replay persistence shall maintain references rather than duplicate constitutional state.
A.7. Replay Artifact Lifecycle
Replay artifacts follow CALM lifecycle governance.
Illustrative lifecycle:
Created
│
▼
Validated
│
▼
Published
│
▼
Federated
│
▼
Archived
Lifecycle transitions shall preserve artifact identity.
A.8. Replay Artifact Characteristics
| Artifact | Immutable | Replayable | Federated | Attestable | DAL Eligible |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Replay Execution | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Context | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Manifest | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Package | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Result | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Telemetry | ✓ | ✓ | Optional | Optional | Optional |
| Replay Archive | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
A.9. Constitutional Framework Relationships
Replay artifacts integrate with the following constitutional frameworks.
| Framework | Relationship |
|---|---|
| CEP | Original execution lineage |
| CRP | Replay execution lineage |
| CIA | Artifact identity |
| CIR | Identifier resolution |
| CALM | Lifecycle governance |
| CPA | Persistence |
| DAL | Integrity anchoring |
| Trust Model | Trust reconstruction |
| TrustGate Attestation Catalog | Assurance reconstruction |
| TG-INTEL | Explainable intelligence |
| TrustGate Federation Profiles | Cross-ECO exchange |
A.10. Constitutional Constraints
Every replay artifact shall:
- possess exactly one canonical identifier;
- preserve immutable lineage;
- preserve provenance;
- remain independently replayable where applicable;
- support constitutional verification;
- remain technology independent.
These constraints are normative.
A.11. Summary
The Canonical Replay Artifact Catalog defines the immutable constitutional artifacts that comprise the TrustGate Replay ecosystem.
By standardizing Replay Executions (RPIDs), Replay Contexts (RCIDs), Replay Manifests (RMIDs), Replay Packages (RPKIDs), Replay Results (RRIDs), Replay Sessions (RSIDs), Replay Telemetry (RTIDs), Replay Archives (RAIDs), Trust Intelligence links (TIIDs), and Replay Federation Exchanges (RFIDs), the TrustGate Replay Specification ensures that replay artifacts remain consistently identifiable, explainable, attestable, interoperable, and reproducible across the ZAYAZ platform and federated ecosystems.
Appendix B — Replay Identifier Reference
B.1. Purpose
This appendix defines the canonical identifier system governing all constitutional artifacts within the TrustGate Replay Specification.
Identifiers provide globally unique, immutable, technology-independent identities for replay artifacts and enable deterministic replay, constitutional lineage, federation, and long-term interoperability.
This appendix is normative.
B.2. Constitutional Identifier Principles
Every Replay identifier shall satisfy the following principles.
Global Uniqueness
Every identifier shall be globally unique.
Immutability
Identifiers shall never change after publication.
Technology Independence
Identifiers shall not encode implementation details.
Constitutional Identity
Every identifier shall identify exactly one constitutional artifact.
Replayability
Every identifier shall support deterministic replay.
B.3. Identifier Categories
Replay identifiers are organized into constitutional categories.
| Category | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Execution | Replay executions and sessions |
| Context | Replay environments and contracts |
| Packages | Replay artifact collections |
| Results | Replay verification outcomes |
| Runtime | Events and telemetry |
| Archives | Long-term preservation |
| Intelligence | Replay intelligence references |
| Federation | Cross-ECO replay exchange |
B.4. Canonical Replay Identifier Catalog
| Identifier | Name | Identifies |
|---|---|---|
| RPID | Replay Identifier | One replay execution |
| RSID | Replay Session Identifier | A coordinated replay session |
| RCID | Replay Context Identifier | Immutable replay context |
| RMID | Replay Manifest Identifier | Replay contract |
| RPKID | Replay Package Identifier | Replay package |
| RRID | Replay Result Identifier | Replay verification result |
| REID | Replay Event Identifier | Individual replay runtime event |
| RTID | Replay Telemetry Identifier | Replay telemetry artifact |
| RAID | Replay Archive Identifier | Archived replay artifact |
| RFID | Replay Federation Identifier | Federated replay exchange |
Each identifier shall identify exactly one constitutional artifact.
B.5. Cross-Framework Identifier Relationships
Replay identifiers reference constitutional identifiers defined by other specifications.
| Identifier | Specification | Purpose |
|---|---|---|
| CSI | Signal Catalog | Canonical signal identity |
| USO | Universal Sustainability Object | Object identity |
| VEVID | Validation Rule Registry | Validation evidence |
| TG-VRES | Validation Rule Registry | Validation result |
| TOID | Trust Model | Trust object |
| TVID | Trust Model | Trust vector |
| TAID | Trust Attestation Catalog | Trust attestation |
| TIID | TG-INTEL | Intelligence artifact |
| DALID | DAL | Ledger anchor |
| ECO Number | Federation | Organization identity |
Replay identifiers shall reference rather than replace constitutional identities.
B.6. Constitutional Identifier Relationships
RPID
│
├────────► RCID
├────────► RMID
├────────► RPKID
├────────► RRID
├────────► RTID
├─────── ─► RAID
├────────► RFID
└────────► TIID
Relationships preserve constitutional lineage.
B.7. Identifier Lifecycle
Identifiers follow CALM governance.
Allocated
│
▼
Published
│
▼
Referenced
│
▼
Federated
│
▼
Archived
Identifiers remain immutable throughout their lifecycle.
B.8. Identifier Scope
| Identifier | Global | Immutable | Federated | Replayable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RPID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| RSID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| RCID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| RMID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| RPKID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| RRID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| REID | ✓ | ✓ | Optional | ✓ |
| RTID | ✓ | ✓ | Optional | ✓ |
| RAID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| RFID | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
B.9. Identifier Resolution
Replay identifiers shall be resolved through the Canonical Identifier Registry (CIR).
Resolution shall provide:
- identifier validation;
- artifact lookup;
- lifecycle state;
- provenance;
- constitutional relationships;
- federation metadata.
Resolution behavior is implementation independent.
B.10. Constitutional Constraints
Every Replay identifier shall:
- identify exactly one constitutional artifact;
- remain immutable;
- preserve constitutional lineage;
- support replay reconstruction;
- remain globally unique;
- remain technology independent.
These constraints are normative.
B.11. Summary
The Replay Identifier Reference defines the constitutional namespace for the TrustGate Replay Specification.
By standardizing Replay Identifiers (RPIDs), Replay Session Identifiers (RSIDs), Replay Context Identifiers (RCIDs), Replay Manifest Identifiers (RMIDs), Replay Package Identifiers (RPKIDs), Replay Result Identifiers (RRIDs), Replay Event Identifiers (REIDs), Replay Telemetry Identifiers (RTIDs), Replay Archive Identifiers (RAIDs), and Replay Federation Identifiers (RFIDs), the specification guarantees globally unique, immutable, replayable, and interoperable constitutional identities across the ZAYAZ platform and federated ecosystems.
Appendix C — Replay Pipeline Reference
C.1. Purpose
This appendix defines the normative reference model for the Canonical Replay Pipeline (CRP).
The CRP specifies the constitutional sequence of replay stages required to deterministically reconstruct, verify, and explain historical constitutional executions.
This appendix is normative.
C.2. Constitutional Principles
The Canonical Replay Pipeline shall satisfy the following principles.
- deterministic execution;
- immutable constitutional inputs;
- complete provenance preservation;
- implementation independence;
- replay equivalence (CRE);
- constitutional explainability.
Every stage shall produce replayable constitutional artifacts.
C.3. Canonical Replay Pipeline (CRP)
The Canonical Replay Pipeline consists of the following normative stages.
Replay Request
│
▼
CRP-01 Context Resolution
│
▼
CRP-02 Artifact Resolution
│
▼
CRP-03 Validation Replay
│
▼
CRP-04 Trust Replay
│
▼
CRP-05 Attestation Replay
│
▼
CRP-06 DAL Replay
│
▼
CRP-07 Federation Replay
│
▼
CRP-08 TG-INTEL Verification
│
▼
CRP-09 Replay Result
│
▼
CRP-10 Replay Telemetry
The CRP reconstructs constitutional execution without modifying constitutional artifacts.
C.4. Replay Stage Reference
| Stage | CRP Code | Constitutional Purpose | Primary Output |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CRP-01 | Resolve replay context | Replay Context (RCID) |
| 2 | CRP-02 | Resolve constitutional artifacts | Replay Package (RPKID) |
| 3 | CRP-03 | Replay validation | Validation Replay Result |
| 4 | CRP-04 | Replay trust computation | Trust Replay Result |
| 5 | CRP-05 | Replay attestations | Replay Attestation Result |
| 6 | CRP-06 | Verify DAL integrity | Integrity Verification |
| 7 | CRP-07 | Verify federation state | Federation Verification |
| 8 | CRP-08 | Verify TG-INTEL provenance | Intelligence Verification |
| 9 | CRP-09 | Produce replay outcome | Replay Result (RRID) |
| 10 | CRP-10 | Publish replay telemetry | Replay Telemetry (RTID) |
C.5. Replay Micro-Engine Reference
Each CRP stage is executed by one or more constitutional replay micro-engines.
| Stage | MEID | Canonical Engine | Primary Responsibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| CRP-01 | TG-RP-001 | Replay Context Engine | Establish immutable replay context |
| CRP-02 | TG-RP-002 | Artifact Resolution Engine | Resolve constitutional artifacts through CIR |
| CRP-03 | TG-RP-003 | Validation Replay Engine | Reconstruct validation execution |
| CRP-04 | TG-RP-004 | Trust Replay Engine | Reconstruct trust computation |
| CRP-05 | TG-RP-005 | Attestation Replay Engine | Reconstruct constitutional attestations |
| CRP-06 | TG-RP-006 | DAL Replay Engine | Verify ledger integrity and anchors |
| CRP-07 | TG-RP-007 | Federation Replay Engine | Verify federation exchange and provenance |
| CRP-08 | TG-RP-008 | TG-INTEL Verification Engine | Verify constitutional intelligence lineage |
| CRP-09 | TG-RP-009 | Replay Result Engine | Produce immutable replay result |
| CRP-10 | TG-RP-010 | Replay Telemetry Engine | Emit replay telemetry |
Every Replay Micro-Engine shall possess a Canonical Managed Identifier (CMI) and a Micro-Engine Identifier (MEID).
C.6. Constitutional Inputs
The Canonical Replay Pipeline consumes immutable constitutional artifacts.
Representative inputs include:
- Replay Context (RCID);
- Replay Manifest (RMID);
- Replay Package (RPKID);
- TG-SIGNAL;
- TG-VRES;
- VEVID;
- TOID;
- TVID;
- TAID;
- TIID;
- DAL Anchors;
- Federation Exchanges.
Replay engines shall consume references rather than duplicate constitutional artifacts.
C.7. Constitutional Outputs
The Canonical Replay Pipeline produces immutable constitutional artifacts.
Representative outputs include:
- Replay Result (RRID);
- Replay Telemetry (RTID);
- Replay Events (REIDs);
- Replay Archive (RAID);
- Replay Verification Reports;
- Federation Replay Evidence.
Outputs shall preserve constitutional lineage.
C.8. Replay Execution Profiles
Replay execution behavior is governed by XPIDs.
Representative profiles include:
| XPID | Purpose |
|---|---|
| XP-LOCAL | Internal replay |
| XP-AUDIT | Independent audit replay |
| XP-REG | Regulatory replay |
| XP-FED | Federated replay |
| XP-FORENSIC | Complete forensic reconstruction |
| XP-TEST | Conformance testing |
Execution Profiles alter operational behavior without changing constitutional semantics.
C.9. Constitutional Relationships
The CRP integrates with the Canonical Execution Pipeline (CEP).
CEP
Collect
│
Observe
│
Validate
│
Trust
│
Attest
│
DAL
│
TG-INTEL
══════════════════════════════════════
CRP
Replay Context
│
Artifacts
│
Validation Replay
│
Trust Replay
│
Attestation Replay
│
DAL Replay
│
Federation Replay
│
TG-INTEL Verification
CEP performs constitutional execution.
CRP reconstructs constitutional execution.
Together they form the constitutional twins of the ZAYAZ platform.
C.10. Constitutional Constraints
The Canonical Replay Pipeline shall:
- execute replay stages in constitutional order;
- preserve replay determinism;
- preserve constitutional lineage;
- preserve replay chronology;
- preserve artifact identity;
- remain implementation independent;
- remain independently explainable.
These constraints are normative.
C.11. Constitutional Invariants
The Canonical Replay Pipeline preserves the following invariant families.
| Invariant Family | Constitutional Requirement |
|---|---|
| IF-100 | Identity Preservation |
| IF-200 | Lineage Preservation |
| IF-300 | Chronology Preservation |
| IF-400 | Replay Determinism |
| IF-500 | Replay Equivalence (CRE) |
| IF-600 | Trust Continuity |
| IF-700 | Attestation Continuity |
| IF-800 | Integrity Preservation |
| IF-900 | Explainability Preservation |
Violation of these invariants constitutes a constitutional replay failure.
C.12. Relationship to Constitutional Frameworks
The Canonical Replay Pipeline integrates with:
| Framework | Constitutional Contribution |
|---|---|
| CEP | Original execution lineage |
| CRP | Replay execution |
| CRE | Replay equivalence |
| CIA | Identity governance |
| CIR | Identifier resolution |
| CALM | Lifecycle governance |
| CPA | Persistence |
| DAL | Integrity verification |
| Validation Rule Registry | Validation replay |
| Trust Model | Trust replay |
| TrustGate Attestation Catalog | Attestation replay |
| TG-INTEL | Intelligence verification |
C.13. Summary
The Replay Pipeline Reference defines the normative execution model for the Canonical Replay Pipeline (CRP).
By standardizing replay stages, micro-engine responsibilities, execution profiles, constitutional inputs and outputs, and their relationships to the Canonical Execution Pipeline (CEP), Canonical Replay Equivalence (CRE), Canonical Identity Architecture (CIA), Canonical Identifier Registry (CIR), Canonical Artifact Lifecycle Model (CALM), Canonical Persistence Architecture (CPA), and the Distributed Assurance Ledger (DAL), the TrustGate Replay Specification guarantees deterministic, explainable, interoperable, and constitutionally equivalent replay across all compliant implementations.
Appendix D — Replay Lifecycle
D.1. Purpose
This appendix defines the constitutional lifecycle governing Replay artifacts within the TrustGate Replay Specification.
The Replay Lifecycle is a specialized profile of the Canonical Artifact Lifecycle Model (CALM) and governs the evolution of Replay artifacts from creation through long-term constitutional preservation.
Replay artifacts are immutable constitutional records.
They are never modified after publication and are never destroyed.
This appendix is normative.
D.2. Constitutional Principles
Replay Lifecycle shall satisfy the following principles.
Immutability
Replay artifacts shall never be modified after publication.
Preservation
Replay artifacts shall remain available for constitutional replay throughout their retention period.
Determinism
Lifecycle transitions shall never alter replay semantics.
Explainability
Every lifecycle transition shall preserve constitutional provenance.
Technology Independence
Lifecycle behavior shall remain independent of implementation.
D.3. Replay Lifecycle Model
Replay artifacts progress through the following constitutional lifecycle.
Allocated
│
▼
Executing
│
▼
Verified
│
▼
Published
│
▼
Referenced
│
▼
Federated
│
▼
Archived
│
▼
Preserved
Lifecycle progression shall preserve constitutional identity.
D.4. Replay Lifecycle States
| State | Constitutional Meaning |
|---|---|
| Allocated | Constitutional identity has been assigned |
| Executing | Replay execution is in progress |
| Verified | Replay execution completed successfully |
| Published | Replay artifacts become immutable constitutional records |
| Referenced | Replay artifacts are referenced by other constitutional artifacts |
| Federated | Replay artifacts have been exchanged across trusted ECOs |
| Archived | Replay artifacts are retained for long-term assurance |
| Preserved | Replay artifacts remain constitutionally available indefinitely |
Replay artifacts shall never transition back to an earlier state.
D.5. Lifecycle State Transitions
The following transitions are permitted.
| From | To |
|---|---|
| Allocated | Executing |
| Executing | Verified |
| Verified | Published |
| Published | Referenced |
| Published | Federated |
| Referenced | Archived |
| Federated | Archived |
| Archived | Preserved |
All other transitions are prohibited unless explicitly defined by future constitutional specifications.
D.6. Constitutional Lifecycle Events
Representative lifecycle events include:
- Replay Requested
- Context Established
- Execution Started
- Verification Completed
- Result Published
- Replay Referenced
- Federation Exchange
- Archive Completed
- Preservation Confirmed
Each event shall possess a Replay Event Identifier (REID).
D.7. Lifecycle Governance
Replay lifecycle governance is provided through CALM.
Lifecycle governance includes:
- state validation;
- transition authorization;
- provenance preservation;
- chronology validation;
- federation policy enforcement;
- archival governance.
Replay lifecycle governance shall remain deterministic.
D.8. Constitutional Relationships
Replay lifecycle interacts with constitutional frameworks.
Replay Execution
│
▼
Replay Result
│
▼
Replay Lifecycle
│
▼
CALM
│
▼
CPA
│
▼
DAL
Lifecycle governance shall preserve constitutional lineage.
D.9. Replay Preservation
Replay preservation is the terminal constitutional state.
Preserved Replay artifacts shall:
- remain immutable;
- remain addressable;
- remain replayable;
- remain verifiable;
- preserve constitutional identity;
- preserve lineage;
- preserve provenance.
Preservation shall not imply active execution.
D.10. Constitutional Constraints
Replay Lifecycle shall satisfy the following requirements.
- Replay artifacts shall never be deleted.
- Replay artifacts shall never lose constitutional identity.
- Replay artifacts shall never lose provenance.
- Lifecycle transitions shall remain deterministic.
- Replay artifacts shall preserve replayability.
- Replay artifacts shall preserve federation compatibility.
These constraints are normative.
D.11. Constitutional Invariants
Replay Lifecycle preserves the following invariant families.
| Invariant Family | Constitutional Requirement |
|---|---|
| IF-100 | Identity Preservation |
| IF-200 | Lifecycle Preservation |
| IF-300 | Chronology Preservation |
| IF-400 | Provenance Preservation |
| IF-500 | Replay Preservation |
| IF-600 | Federation Preservation |
| IF-700 | Explainability Preservation |
Violation of these invariants constitutes a constitutional lifecycle failure.
D.12. Relationship to Constitutional Frameworks
Replay Lifecycle integrates with:
| Framework | Constitutional Contribution |
|---|---|
| CALM | Lifecycle governance |
| CPA | Persistent storage |
| CIA | Identity management |
| CIR | Identifier resolution |
| CRP | Replay execution |
| CRE | Replay equivalence |
| DAL | Integrity preservation |
| TG-INTEL | Intelligence lineage |
| TrustGate Federation Profiles | Cross-ECO lifecycle continuity |
Replay Lifecycle complements these frameworks without redefining them.
D.13. Summary
The Replay Lifecycle defines the constitutional evolution of Replay artifacts throughout their operational and preservation lifecycle.
By governing Replay artifacts through immutable lifecycle states, deterministic transitions, constitutional provenance, federation continuity, and long-term preservation under CALM, CPA, CIA, CIR, CRP, CRE, and DAL, the TrustGate Replay Specification guarantees that replay evidence remains reproducible, explainable, interoperable, and constitutionally available for the lifetime of the ZAYAZ platform.
Appendix E — Replay Conformance Levels
E.1. Purpose
This appendix defines the constitutional conformance levels governing implementations of the TrustGate Replay Specification.
Replay Conformance establishes the minimum constitutional capabilities required for deterministic replay, interoperability, replay equivalence, and long-term assurance across the ZAYAZ ecosystem.
This appendix is normative.
E.2. Constitutional Principles
Every conforming Replay implementation shall satisfy the following principles.
- deterministic replay;
- immutable constitutional identity;
- replay equivalence (CRE);
- implementation independence;
- constitutional explainability;
- interoperability.
Higher conformance levels include all requirements of lower levels.
E.3. Constitutional Conformance Model
Replay implementations are evaluated along two constitutional dimensions.
Capability
▲
│
TG-RC4 │ Constitutional Replay
│
TG-RC3 │ Federated Replay
│
TG-RC2 │ Assured Replay
│
TG-RC1 │ Basic Replay
│
────────────────┼────────────────────────────►
Constitutional Replay
Equivalence (CRE)
Capability determines what an implementation supports.
Replay Equivalence determines whether independent implementations produce constitutionally equivalent replay outcomes.
E.4. Replay Conformance Levels
| Level | Designation | Constitutional Scope |
|---|---|---|
| TG-RC1 | Basic Replay | Deterministic replay of constitutional artifacts |
| TG-RC2 | Assured Replay | Validation Replay, Trust Replay, Attestation Replay |
| TG-RC3 | Federated Replay | Cross-ECO replay, Replay Packages, Federation Replay |
| TG-RC4 | Constitutional Replay | Full CRP, CRE, DAL verification, TG-INTEL verification, CIA, CIR, CALM and CPA compliance |
Each level includes all requirements of preceding levels.
E.5. Capability Matrix
| Capability | RC1 | RC2 | RC3 | RC4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Canonical Replay Pipeline (CRP) | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Context | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Package | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Validation Replay | — | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Trust Replay | — | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Attestation Replay | — | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| DAL Replay | — | — | ✓ | ✓ |
| Federation Replay | — | — | ✓ | ✓ |
| Replay Telemetry | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| TG-INTEL Verification | — | — | — | ✓ |
| Replay Equivalence (CRE) | — | Partial | ✓ | ✓ |
E.6. Constitutional Framework Compliance
| Framework | RC1 | RC2 | RC3 | RC4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CIA | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| CIR | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| CALM | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| CPA | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| CEP (lineage) | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| CRP | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| CRE | — | Partial | ✓ | ✓ |
| DAL | — | — | ✓ | ✓ |
| Validation Rule Registry | — | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Trust Model | — | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| TrustGate Attestation Catalog | — | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| TG-INTEL | — | — | — | ✓ |
| Federation Profiles | — | — | ✓ | ✓ |
E.7. Canonical Replay Equivalence
Replay implementations achieving TG-RC3 or higher shall satisfy Canonical Replay Equivalence (CRE).
Replay executions are constitutionally equivalent when they preserve:
- replay identity;
- replay lineage;
- replay chronology;
- validation outcomes;
- trust outcomes;
- attestation outcomes;
- DAL verification;
- replay outcome semantics.
Implementation details are explicitly excluded from equivalence determination.
E.8. Constitutional Certification
Replay implementations may undergo constitutional certification.
Certification evaluates:
- CRP compliance;
- CRE compliance;
- deterministic replay;
- identifier compliance;
- lifecycle compliance;
- persistence compliance;
- federation interoperability;
- explainability.
Certification artifacts shall themselves be replayable constitutional artifacts.
E.9. Constitutional Constraints
Every conforming implementation shall:
- preserve constitutional identity;
- preserve replay determinism;
- preserve replay chronology;
- preserve replay lineage;
- preserve replay provenance;
- preserve replay explainability;
- remain implementation independent.
These constraints are normative.
E.10. Constitutional Invariants
Replay Conformance preserves the following invariant families.
| Invariant Family | Constitutional Requirement |
|---|---|
| IF-100 | Identity Preservation |
| IF-200 | Lineage Preservation |
| IF-300 | Replay Determinism |
| IF-400 | Replay Equivalence (CRE) |
| IF-500 | Replay Explainability |
| IF-600 | Replay Integrity |
| IF-700 | Federation Compatibility |
| IF-800 | Constitutional Compliance |
Violation of these invariants constitutes constitutional non-conformance.
E.11. Relationship to Constitutional Frameworks
Replay Conformance integrates with:
| Framework | Constitutional Contribution |
|---|---|
| CEP | Original execution lineage |
| CRP | Replay execution |
| CRE | Replay equivalence |
| CIA | Identity governance |
| CIR | Identifier resolution |
| CALM | Lifecycle governance |
| CPA | Persistence |
| DAL | Integrity verification |
| Validation Rule Registry | Validation replay |
| Trust Model | Trust replay |
| TrustGate Attestation Catalog | Attestation replay |
| TG-INTEL | Intelligence verification |
| TrustGate Federation Profiles | Cross-ECO interoperability |
E.12. Summary
The Replay Conformance Levels define the constitutional maturity model for implementations of the TrustGate Replay Specification.
By classifying implementations from Basic Replay (TG-RC1) through Constitutional Replay (TG-RC4), and by requiring compliance with the Canonical Replay Pipeline (CRP), Canonical Replay Equivalence (CRE), Canonical Identity Architecture (CIA), Canonical Identifier Registry (CIR), Canonical Artifact Lifecycle Model (CALM), Canonical Persistence Architecture (CPA), the Distributed Assurance Ledger (DAL), and the TrustGate constitutional framework family, this appendix guarantees that replay remains deterministic, explainable, interoperable, independently verifiable, and constitutionally equivalent across all compliant implementations.
Appendix F — Replay Invariant Families
F.1. Purpose
This appendix defines the constitutional invariant families governing all implementations of the TrustGate Replay Specification.
Replay invariants establish the immutable constitutional properties that every Replay implementation shall preserve, regardless of implementation technology, deployment architecture, or federation topology.
Violation of a constitutional invariant constitutes Replay non-conformance.
This appendix is normative.
F.2. Constitutional Principles
Replay invariants shall satisfy the following principles.
- permanence;
- implementation independence;
- deterministic verification;
- constitutional explainability;
- interoperability;
- auditability.
Replay invariants shall never depend upon implementation-specific behavior.
F.3. Constitutional Invariant Model
Replay invariants are organized hierarchically.
Invariant Family (IF)
│
├────────► Constitutional Invariant (CI)
│
├────────► Verification Rule
│
└────────► Conformance Evidence
Invariant Families define constitutional domains.
Constitutional Invariants define individual normative requirements.
F.4. Replay Invariant Families
| Family | Constitutional Domain |
|---|---|
| IF-100 | Identity Preservation |
| IF-200 | Lineage Preservation |
| IF-300 | Replay Determinism |
| IF-400 | Replay Equivalence (CRE) |
| IF-500 | Provenance Preservation |
| IF-600 | Integrity Preservation |
| IF-700 | Trust Continuity |
| IF-800 | Attestation Continuity |
| IF-900 | Federation Continuity |
| IF-1000 | Explainability Preservation |
Every Replay implementation shall preserve every invariant family.
F.5. Constitutional Invariants
Illustrative constitutional invariants include:
| CI | Requirement |
|---|---|
| CI-101 | Every Replay artifact possesses exactly one immutable constitutional identity. |
| CI-102 | Constitutional identities shall never change after publication. |
| CI-201 | Replay lineage shall remain complete. |
| CI-202 | Parent-child constitutional relationships shall remain immutable. |
| CI-301 | Equivalent Replay inputs shall produce constitutionally equivalent Replay outputs. |
| CI-302 | Replay stage ordering shall remain deterministic. |
| CI-401 | Replay Equivalence (CRE) shall compare constitutional semantics rather than implementation details. |
| CI-501 | Replay provenance shall remain reconstructable. |
| CI-601 | DAL verification shall preserve integrity evidence. |
| CI-701 | Trust reconstruction shall preserve trust semantics. |
| CI-801 | Replayed attestations shall remain constitutionally equivalent to original attestations. |
| CI-901 | Federation replay shall preserve constitutional identities across ECOs. |
| CI-1001 | Every replay outcome shall remain independently explainable. |
Future specifications may extend this catalog without altering existing invariants.
F.6. Verification Model
Every constitutional invariant shall be objectively verifiable.
Verification evidence may include:
- Replay Results (RRIDs);
- Replay Packages (RPKIDs);
- Replay Telemetry (RTIDs);
- Replay Events (REIDs);
- Replay Archives (RAIDs);
- DAL verification evidence;
- Federation exchange evidence;
- TG-INTEL provenance.
Verification shall remain implementation independent.
F.7. Constitutional Relationships
Replay invariants govern the entire Replay ecosystem.
Replay Runtime
│
▼
Replay Pipeline (CRP)
│
▼
Replay Artifacts
│
▼
Replay Invariants
│
▼
Replay Conformance
Every constitutional artifact shall remain subject to Replay invariant verification.
F.8. Constitutional Framework Relationships
Replay invariants integrate with:
| Framework | Constitutional Contribution |
|---|---|
| CIA | Identity invariants |
| CIR | Identifier resolution invariants |
| CALM | Lifecycle invariants |
| CPA | Persistence invariants |
| CEP | Execution lineage invariants |
| CRP | Replay execution invariants |
| CRE | Replay equivalence invariants |
| DAL | Integrity invariants |
| Validation Rule Registry | Validation invariants |
| Trust Model | Trust invariants |
| TrustGate Attestation Catalog | Attestation invariants |
| TG-INTEL | Explainability invariants |
F.9. Constitutional Constraints
Replay implementations shall:
- preserve every constitutional invariant;
- reject invariant violations;
- produce verifiable invariant evidence;
- preserve deterministic verification;
- remain implementation independent.
These constraints are normative.
F.10. Constitutional Verification
Replay conformance verification shall evaluate:
✓ Identity Preservation
✓ Lineage Preservation
✓ Replay Determinism
✓ Replay Equivalence (CRE)
✓ Provenance Preservation
✓ Integrity Preservation
✓ Trust Continuity
✓ Attestation Continuity
✓ Federation Continuity
✓ Explainability Preservation
Failure of any verification constitutes constitutional non-conformance.
F.11. Future Evolution
Future constitutional specifications may introduce additional invariant families, including:
- AI governance invariants;
- constitutional optimization invariants;
- autonomous verification invariants;
- zero-knowledge replay invariants;
- post-quantum integrity invariants.
Existing invariant families shall remain backward compatible.
F.12. Summary
The Replay Invariant Families define the immutable constitutional properties governing deterministic replay throughout the ZAYAZ platform.
By organizing constitutional requirements into Invariant Families (IF-100 through IF-1000) and individually verifiable Constitutional Invariants (CI-xxx), the TrustGate Replay Specification provides a scalable and implementation-independent framework for certification, conformance testing, federation, auditing, and long-term constitutional assurance.